Thanks to Brig. Vipin Chakrawarti, appellant also submitted appeal by using appropriate platform which Diary Number-651224



Gmail Mahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P Singh <yogimpsingh@gmail.com>

Online appeal application submitted

1 message

Central Information Commission (CIC) <no-reply@nic.in> 7 November 2023 at 17:29

To: yogimpsingh@gmail.com

Cc: feedback-cic@gov.in

Dear Yogi M P Singh,

Your online appeal is diarised. Details are given below:

1 Diary Number 651224

2 Diary date 07-11-2023

Please logon to : www.cic.gov.in for any further details.

Regards,

Central Information Commission (CIC)

Gmail Mahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P Singh <yogimpsingh@gmail.com>

Not a single information is being provided by the central public information officer of the Punjab National Bank and first appellate authority blindly supports it.

Brig. Vipin Chakrawarti <registrar-cic@gov.in> 8 November 2023 at 12:28

To: yogimpsingh@gmail.com

Sir/Madam,

I am sorry to say that email/whatsapp/SMS/RTI application/CPGRAM etc. are not the proper platforms or modes to file Second Appeal/complaint/associated documents etc. related to them. It is intimated that the same can only be filed in Central Information Commission either physically by post or by using online portal of the Commission (https://cic.gov.in/) using the designated link available therein or through mobile app.

As such, you may like to file a second appeal or a complaint in the Commission as per Rule 8 of RTI Rules 2012 (preferably in the format as given in the Appendix referred therein while addressing it to this Commission) while enclosing self-attested legible copies of all documents mentioned in said Rule; either physically by post or by using online facility as described above.

For any further query, the appellant may like to contact facilitation desk at tele no. 011-26183053 (direct number) or at 011-26767500 (Extension Nos. 300 and 444).

Regards

Brig. Vipin Chakrawarti

Registrar

Central Information Commission

CIC Bhawan, Baba Gangnath Marg,

Munirka, New Delhi - 110067.

From: yogimpsingh@gmail.com

To: "Rashmi Chowdhary" <secy-cic@nic.in>, "Brig. Vipin Chakrawarti" <registrar-cic@nic.in>, "sk chowdhary" <sk.chowdhary@pnb.co.in>, "niraj sinha" <niraj.sinha@pnb.co.in>, mohansingla@pnb.co.in

Sent: Tuesday, November 7, 2023 4:12:25 PM

Subject: Not a single information is being provided by the central public information officer of the Punjab National Bank and first appellate authority blindly supports it.

An appeal under subsection 3 of section 19 of the right to information act 2005 against central public information officer Punjab National Bank who did not provide the information to the appellant on the flimsy ground while the matter concerns the deep rooted corruption in the working of the public authority Punjab National Bank.

To

                                  Chief Information Commissioner of India

                                      The Central Information Commission,

                                            Baba Gangnath Marg, Munirka,

                                                    New Delhi - 110 067

Appellant –Yogi M. P. Singh, Mohalla-Surekapuram,Shri Laxmi Narayan Baikunth Mahadev Mandir ,

Riva Road, District-Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh, Pin code -231001, Mobile number-7379105911

                Versus

1-Central Public Information Officer, Punjab National Bank, CO Bulandshahr Sujeet Chaudhary

Phone: 05732-281724

sk.chowdhary@pnb.co.in 

2-First Appellate Authority, Punjab National Bank, CO Bulandshahr Niraj Kumar Sinha

Phone: 05732-281724

niraj.sinha@pnb.co.in

Prayer-Instead of pursuing the path of negative approach of not providing information, CPIO Punjab National Bank must provide the information to information seeker/appellant in the matter concerning deep rooted corruption, lawlessness and anarchy lowering the dignity of the nationalized banks due to lack of transparency and accountability in the working. It is most surprising that the first appellate authority of the Punjab National Bank instead of taking perusal of the contents of the first appeal he blindly copied the denial of information provided by the central public information officer and provided it to the appellant. 

Description of Information Sought

RTI application is attached to this online application in PDF form. Please open the PDF document and read each point of the information then provide the information in the same way as your applicant is seeking.

Bank Name: Punjab National Bank (PNB), Branch Name: Bulandshahr R M Office

The Punjab National Bank Bulandshahr R M Office Branch is in Bulandshahr district of Uttar Pradesh. Bulandshahr district has a total 88 Punjab National Bank branches including Bulandshahr R M Office.

Central public information officer may provide the following information to the information seeker point wise as follows.

1-Central public information officer may provide the posting details of the following branch manager whose details are as follows.

Branch - PNB Civil lines, Bulandshahr, Branch Manager - Akhilesh, Mobile no- +917428025901 and Branch Office mail-bo0069@pnb.co.in

This information must include the date of joining to the circle and concerned branch as mentioned above.

Denial of Information by central public information officer/(Kamal Kishor Thakur) C.P.I.O. Punjab National Bank is as follows.

The information sought by you relates to personal information of a third party and since no involvement of larger public interest has been established the same cannot be provided in light of exemption under section 8 (1) (1) of the RTI Act, 2005.

Submission of the appellant is as follows.

CPIO must know that branch manager is not a third party and his posting details concerns with the working of the public authority so there must be transparency and accountability in the working of the public authority for which right to Information Act was introduced by the government of India. There denial of information by CPIO is illegal, arbitrary and ultra vires to the provisions of the Right to Information Act 2005.

2-If the aforementioned branch manager transferred within the circle then provide the transfer details.

Denial of Information by central public information officer/(Kamal Kishor Thakur) C.P.I.O. Punjab National Bank is as follows.

query, which is not covered under the definition of 'Information' u/s 2(f) of the RTI Act, 2005. Hence, the same cannot be provided. Information sought is not clear & specific, Hence is not covered u/s 2(f) of the RTI Act, 2005.

Submission of the appellant is as follows.

CPIO had to provide transfer details of the branch manager if branch manager was transferred within the circle by public authority.

But this information also denied by CPIO on the false flimsy ground because of corruption which pressed them to live in fear psychosis.


3-Central public information officer may provide the posting details of the staff who belong to the loan section of the Bulandshahr R M Office of the Punjab National Bank (PNB).

Denial of Information by central public information officer/(Kamal Kishor Thakur) C.P.I.O. Punjab National Bank is as follows.

Information sought is not clear & specific, Hence is not covered u/s 2(f) of the RTI Act, 2005.

Submission of the appellant is as follows.

There are specific staff who works in the loan section of the RM office deals with the matter concerning loans but posting details are denied because they are working on the same table for many years likewise branch manager and enjoying plum posting.

4-Central public information officer may provide the posting details of the monitoring head of the loan section of the Bulandshahr R M Office of the Punjab National Bank (PNB) as well as name and designation.

Denial of Information by central public information officer/(Kamal Kishor Thakur) C.P.I.O. Punjab National Bank is as follows.

Information sought is not clear & specific, Hence is not covered u/s 2(f) of the RTI Act, 2005.

Submission of the appellant is as follows.

There is a loan section in RM office and its monitoring head supervises its working deals with the matter concerning loans but posting details are denied because he is working on the same table for many years likewise branch manager and enjoying plum posting.

5-Please provide the non-performing assets of the Branch - PNB Civil lines, Bulandshahr, Branch Manager - Akhilesh, Mobile no- +917428025901 and Branch Office mail-bo0069@pnb.co.in of the financial year 2015-16.

6-Please provide the non-performing assets of the Branch - PNB Civil lines, Bulandshahr, Branch Manager - Akhilesh, Mobile no- +917428025901 and Branch Office mail-bo0069@pnb.co.in  of the financial year 2016-17.

7-Please provide the non-performing assets of the Branch - PNB Civil lines, Bulandshahr, Branch Manager - Akhilesh, Mobile no- +917428025901 and Branch Office mail-bo0069@pnb.co.in  of the financial year 2017-18.

8-Please provide the non-performing assets of the Branch - PNB Civil lines, Bulandshahr, Branch Manager - Akhilesh, Mobile no- +917428025901 and Branch Office mail-bo0069@pnb.co.in of the financial year 2018-19.

9-Please provide the non-performing assets of the Branch - PNB Civil lines, Bulandshahr, Branch Manager - Akhilesh, Mobile no- +917428025901 and Branch Office mail-bo0069@pnb.co.in  of the financial year 2019-20.

10-Please provide the non-performing assets of the Branch - PNB Civil lines, Bulandshahr, Branch Manager - Akhilesh, Mobile no- +917428025901 and Branch Office mail-bo0069@pnb.co.in of the financial year 2020-21.

11-Please provide the non-performing assets of the Branch - PNB Civil lines, Bulandshahr, Branch Manager - Akhilesh, Mobile no- +917428025901 and Branch Office mail-bo0069@pnb.co.in of the financial year 2021-22.

12-Please provide the non-performing assets of the Branch - PNB Civil lines, Bulandshahr, Branch Manager - Akhilesh, Mobile no- +917428025901 and Branch Office mail-bo0069@pnb.co.in of the financial year 2022-23.

Denial of Information by central public information officer/(Kamal Kishor Thakur) C.P.I.O. Punjab National Bank is as follows.

The information sought by you under points 5 to 12 is not available in the manner sought and the collection and compilation of the same would divert the resources of the bank disproportionately. Hence, the same is exempted from disclosure as per section 7 (9) of the RTI Act, 2005.

Submission of the appellant is as follows.

CPIO must see the following information provided by the CPIO bank of India as follows and a consistent argument will be made in CIC. Whether following information diverted the resources of Bank of India disproportionately.

Registration Number BKOIN/R/E/22/00135, Name Yogi M P Singh, Received Date 09/02/2022, Public Authority Bank of India

Status REQUEST DISPOSED OF, Date of action 15/03/2022

Reply :- As per information provided by the respective branch point-wise reply of the information sought by you is reproduced below:-

1. The non-performing assets of the Mirzapur city Branch of Bank of India located at Wellesley Ganj of the financial year 2015-16 is Rs. 61910994.00

2. The non-performing assets of the Mirzapur city Branch of Bank of India located at Wellesley Ganj of the financial year 2016-17 is Rs. 65010941.00

3. The non-performing assets of the Mirzapur city Branch of Bank of India located at Wellesley Ganj of the financial year 2017-18 is Rs. 61825000.00

4. The non-performing assets of the Mirzapur city Branch of Bank of India located at Wellesley Ganj of the financial year 2018-19 is Rs. 55450840.10

5. The non-performing assets of the Mirzapur city Branch of Bank of India located at Wellesley Ganj of the financial year 2019-20 is Rs. 60116857.77

6. The non-performing assets of the Mirzapur city Branch of Bank of India located at Wellesley Ganj of the financial year 2020-21 is Rs. 61467631.78

CPIO Details :- VARANASI - TAPAN KUMAR MANDAL

Phone: 0542-2518478

Varanasi[dot]GOD[at]bankofindia[dot]co[dot]in

Most respected sir both the central public information officer and the first appellate authority of the Punjab National Bank are running away from providing information concerning non-performing assets while the same information has been provided by central public information officer bank of India which means there is no transparency and accountability in the working of the Punjab National Bank and they are concealing information from the information seeker because of rampant corruption in the working of the public authority.

13-Please provide detail if the aforementioned information if available under subsection 1 B of section 4 of the Right to Information Act 2005 as required voluntary disclosure of information by the public authorities concerning its working, structure and so many others in wide public interest under R.T.I. Act 2005.

They did not provide information under this point also because no such information has been voluntarily disclosed by Punjab National Bank because of its cryptic and mysterious working style in order to conceal the rampant corruption in the working of the public authority.

This is a humble request of the appellant to you Hon’ble Sir that how can it be justified to withhold public services arbitrarily and promote anarchy, lawlessness, and chaos in an arbitrary manner by making the mockery of law of land? This is the need of the hour to take harsh steps against the wrongdoers in order to win the confidence of citizenry and strengthen the democratic values for healthy and prosperous democracy. For this, your applicant shall ever pray to you, Hon’ble Sir.                                                        

                                                                               Yours sincerely

Date-07/11/2023              Yogi M. P. Singh, Mobile number-7379105911, Mohalla- Surekapuram, Riva Road, District-Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh, Pin code-231001.


Yogi

An anti-corruption crusader. Motive to build a strong society based on the principle of universal brotherhood. Human rights defender and RTI activist. Working for the betterment of societies and as an anti-corruption crusader for more than 25 years. Our sole motive is to raise the voices of weaker and downtrodden sections of the society and safeguard their human rights. Our motive is to promote the religion of universal brotherhood among the various castes communities of different religions. Man is great by his deeds and character.

Post a Comment

Whatever comments you make, it is your responsibility to use facts. You may not make unwanted imputations against any body which may be baseless otherwise commentator itself will be responsible for the derogatory remarks made against any body proved to be false at any appropriate forum.

Previous Post Next Post