Because of poor network connectivity, second appeal was submitted two times

 

Second appeal filed against Niraj Kumar Sinha and Kamal Kishor Thakur of CO Bulandshahr in CIC for not providing information

DAK Entry Details

DAK Entry Details

DAK received Date : 07-11-2023Letter Dated : NA

Letter Number : NADiary Number : 651224

DAK Classification

Appeal/Complaint No. : NAChoose Category : NA

Sender Details

Sender Belongs to : NAMode Of Communication : NA

Name : Yogi M P SinghGender : Male

Country : IndiaDealing Officer/Registry : Central Registration

Remarks : NA

Gmail Mahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P Singh <yogimpsingh@gmail.com>

Return of duplicate Second Appeal/Complaint along with all documents.

1 message

Central Information Commission (CIC) <no-reply@nic.in> 21 November 2023 at 11:00

To: yogimpsingh@gmail.com

Dear Madam/Sir,

Your request details are given below :

1 Appellant Name Yogi M P Singh

2 Address Surekapuram Colony, Shri Laxmi Narayan Baikunth Mahadev Mandir, Riva Road,

3 Diary Number 651224

4 Diary Date 07-11-2023

5 Letter Date 01-01-1970

Your Dak651224has been returned vide Facilitation Memo dated21/11/2023. Please find below link to view the Facilitation Memo: http://dsscic.nic.in/appeal-comp-status-dak-file/search_dak/2?opt=diaryNo&diary_year=2023&search_key=diary_number&search_value=651224&search_button= -CIC

Regards,

Central Information Commission (CIC)

Online Appeal has been submitted successfully & Email has been sent on Applicant Email Id. & Your diary number is:651224

Gmail Mahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P Singh <yogimpsingh@gmail.com>

Online appeal application submitted

1 message

Central Information Commission (CIC) <no-reply@nic.in> 7 November 2023 at 17:29

To: yogimpsingh@gmail.com

Cc: feedback-cic@gov.in

Dear Yogi M P Singh,

Your online appeal is diarized. Details are given below:

1 Diary Number 651224

2 Diary date 07-11-2023

Please logon to : www.cic.gov.in for any further details.

Regards,

Central Information Commission (CIC)

To see the second appeal attached to the online second appeal, please click on the link

Request for condonation of delay returned arbitrarily by CR-1 of CIC by considering it as second appeal so information sought from CPIO, CIC

Your RTI Request filed successfully.

Please note down the following details for further references

Registration Number CICOM/R/E/23/00853

Name Yogi M P Singh

Date of Filing 26-07-2023

RTI Fee Received 10

Payment Mode Internet Banking, Credit or Debit Card / RuPay Card, UPI

SBI Reference number IK0CJJQNZ5

Transaction Status Completed Successfully

Request filed with Central Information Commission

  Contact Details  

Telephone Number 011-26172690

Email Id rticell@cic.nic.in

Online RTI Request Form Details

RTI Request Details :-

   

RTI Request Registration number CICOM/R/E/23/00853

Public Authority Central Information Commission

   

Personal Details of RTI Applicant:-

Name Yogi M P Singh

Gender Male

Address Surekapuram colony, Shri Laxmi Narayan Baikunth Ma , Riva Road, Mirzapur city PIN Code 231001

Country India

State Uttar Pradesh

Status Urban

Educational Status Literate

  Above Graduate

Phone Number Details not provided

Mobile Number +91-7379105911

Email-ID yogimpsingh[at]gmail[dot]com

Request Details :-

Citizenship Indian

Is the Requester Below Poverty Line ? No

(Description of Information sought (upto 500 characters)

Description of Information Sought

According to the communication of the deputy registrar CR-1 dated 15-05-2023, communication of the applicant dated 09-05-2023 received on 12-05-2023 attached as first and second page.

1-Second page is the request for condonation of delay on the format provided by the central registry. Let me tell you the reason for considering it as a second appeal.

2-Tell me the name and designation of the staff who dealt with it.

Concerned CPIO Nodal Officer

Supporting document (only pdf upto 1 MB)

Enter Registration Number CICOM/R/E/23/00853

Name Yogi M P Singh

Received Date 26/07/2023

Public Authority Central Information Commission

Status RTI REQUEST RECEIVED

Date of action 26/07/2023

Nodal Officer Details :-

Telephone Number 011-26172690

Email Id rticell[at]cic[dot]nic[dot]in

Central Information CommissionCIC Bhawan. Munirka Baba Gangnath MargNew Delhi - 110 066File no. CICOM/R/A/23/00191ToDated 11.07.2023Shri Yogi M.P SinghSurekhapuram Colony Shri Laxmi Narayan Baikunth M Pin Code 231001Riva RoadMirzapur CitySub: Compliance to the First Appellate Authority order dated 04.07.2023.Sir,As per the directions dated 04.07.2013 of FAA, in RTI First Appeal No. CICOM/R/A/23/00191, The point wise reply is as under:In Compliance with the order of the FAA the following information is furnished: 1 The Diary Number 625103 received on 23.05.2023 has been handeld by following staff: Mr Surinder DEO in Central Registry2 The request for condonation was made thorugh email and not by Post or Online submission. The Commission did not entertain any request related to Second Appeal/Complaint received through Email. The applicants have to submit the Second Appeal/Complaints and all link papers either through online made in case RTI Application is Online or through post in case it is submitted through Post. In the instant case condonation request for Diary No 620495 was sent by email was marked to secretary which was not received by Central Registry. Secondly the applicant has attach same email while sending his documents by post received on 12.05.2023. Re forwarding the same email by Post does not constitute prescribed format which sould be addressed to commission in an application format hence Second Appeal was not registered on ground of deficiency in regard to being time barred and condonation not submitted in prescribed format.Copy to:-1. Ms Roop Avtar Kaur Additional Secretary & FAA CIC 2. Shri Subodh Kumar Nodal Officer and CPIO RTI Cell.(Sharad Kumar) DR& CPIOCentral Registry - 1The cedler(Sharad Kumar) DR & CPIOCentral Registry - 1

To see the attached document to the RTI Application, click on the link

ROOP AVTAR KAUR designated as FAA in CIC directed DO IC(KY)-Prakash to revisit RTI Application and provide point wise information

(Description of Information sought (upto 500 characters)

Description of Information Sought

Diary Number 625103, received on 23-05-2023 Yogi M P Singh Surekapuram colony, Shri Laxmi

Narayan Baikunth Mahadev Mandir, Riva Road, Mirzapur city, PIN Code-231001

1-Provide name and designation of staff processed aforementioned diary.

2-Condonation of delay request attached to second appeal not considered. Please provide the reason. Vide attached document.

Concerned CPIO DO IC(KY)-Prakash 

Online RTI First Appeal Status Form

Enter Registration Number CICOM/A/E/23/00191

Name Yogi M P Singh

Received Date 13/06/2023

Public Authority Central Information Commission

Status APPEAL DISPOSED OF

Date of action 04/07/2023

Reply :- Ref RTI No.- CICOM/R/E/23/00583

GROUNDS FOR FIRST APPEAL:

The Appellant submitted first appeal stating that

“Where is the name and designation of the staff who processed Diary Number 625103, received on 23-05-2023? This implies incomplete information. Under point 2, CPIO said that request for condonation of delay is not in proper format. Request for condonation of delay received on 12 May 2023 to comply with communication dated 28/04.2023 in respect of diary number-620495/2023. But Deputy registrar CR-1 on 15 May 2023 sought a copy of first appeal and index of documents. Now the same request of condonation of delay attached to the second appeal is not in proper format. Here integrity of staff who processed is under cloud.”

DECISION OF THE FIRST APPELLATE AUTHORITY:

The First Appeal, RTI application and reply given by CPIO of CIC have been perused.

In the instant case, CPIO (DR to CR-I) is directed to revisit the RTI application and provide a point-wise reply to the RTI application as per the provisions of the RTI Act, 2005 by 13.07.2023.

The appeal is disposed of accordingly.

First Appellate Authority Details :- Ms[dot] ROOP AVTAR KAUR

Phone: 011-26162290

as-cic[at]nic[dot]in

Nodal Officer Details :-

Telephone Number 011-26172690

Email Id rticell[at]cic[dot]nic[dot]in

Online RTI Appeal Form Details

RTI Appeal Details :-

   

RTI Appeal Registration number CICOM/A/E/23/00191

Public Authority Central Information Commission

   

Personal Details of Appellant:-

Request Registration Number CICOM/R/E/23/00583

Request Registration Date 02/06/2023

Name Yogi M P Singh

Gender Male

Address Surekapuram Colony , Shri Laxmi Narayan Baikunth M , Riva Road, Mirzapur city PIN Code 231001

Country India

State Uttar Pradesh

Status Urban

Educational Status Literate

  Above Graduate

Phone Number +91-7379105911

Mobile Number +91-7379105911

Email-ID yogimpsingh[at]gmail[dot]com

Appeal Details :-

Citizenship Indian

Is the Requester Below Poverty Line ? No

Ground For Appeal Provided Incomplete,Misleading or False Information

CPIO of Public Authority approached DO IC(KY)-Prakash

CPIO's Order/Decision Number Details not provided

CPIO's Order/Decision Date

(Description of Information sought (upto 500 characters)

Prayer or Relief Sought

Where is the name and designation of the staff who processed Diary Number 625103, received on 23-05-2023? This implies incomplete information. Under point 2, CPIO said that request for condonation of delay is not in proper format. Request for condonation of delay received on 12 May 2023 to comply with communication dated 28/04.2023 in respect of diary number-620495/2023. But Deputy registrar CR-1 on 15 May 2023 sought a copy of first appeal and index of documents. Now the same request of condonation of delay attached to the second appeal is not in proper format. Here integrity of staff who processed is under cloud.

Supporting document (only pdf upto 1 MB)

To see the attached document to the RTI Application, click on the link

CPIO, central information commission provided incomplete and misleading information in regard to request of condonation of delay

Enter Registration Number CICOM/R/E/23/00583

Name Yogi M P Singh

Received Date 02/06/2023

Public Authority Central Information Commission

Status REQUEST DISPOSED OF

Date of action 13/06/2023

Reply :- Reply attached

View Document

CPIO Details :- CENTRAL REGISTRY - I - SHARAD KUMAR

Phone: 011-26717353

drcr1[at]cic[dot]nic[dot]in

First Appellate Authority Details :- Ms[dot] ROOP AVTAR KAUR

Phone: 011-26162290

as-cic[at]nic[dot]in

Nodal Officer Details :-

Telephone Number 011-26172690

Email Id rticell[at]cic[dot]nic[dot]in

Online RTI Request Form Details

RTI Request Details :-

   

RTI Request Registration number CICOM/R/E/23/00583

Public Authority Central Information Commission

   

Personal Details of RTI Applicant:-

Name Yogi M P Singh

Gender Male

Address Surekapuram Colony , Shri Laxmi Narayan Baikunth M , Riva Road, Mirzapur city PIN Code 231001

Country India

State Uttar Pradesh

Status Urban

Educational Status Literate

  Above Graduate

Phone Number +91-7379105911

Mobile Number +91-7379105911

Email-ID yogimpsingh[at]gmail[dot]com

Request Details :-

Citizenship Indian

Is the Requester Below Poverty Line ? No

(Description of Information sought (upto 500 characters)

Description of Information Sought

Diary Number 625103, received on 23-05-2023 Yogi M P Singh Surekapuram colony, Shri Laxmi

Narayan Baikunth Mahadev Mandir, Riva Road, Mirzapur city, PIN Code-231001

1-Provide name and designation of staff processed aforementioned diary.

2-Condonation of delay request attached to second appeal not considered. Please provide the reason. Vide attached document.

Concerned CPIO DO IC(KY)-Prakash

Supporting document (only pdf upto 1 MB)

Your RTI Appeal filed successfully.

Please note down the details of registration.

Registration Number CICOM/A/E/23/00191

Name Yogi M P Singh

Date of Filing 13-06-2023

Appeal filed with Central Information Commission

 Contact Details  

Telephone Number 011-26172690

Email Id rticell@cic.nic.in

Online RTI Appeal Form Details

RTI Appeal Details :-

   

RTI Appeal Registration number CICOM/A/E/23/00191

Public Authority Central Information Commission

   

Personal Details of Appellant:-

Request Registration Number CICOM/R/E/23/00583

Request Registration Date 02/06/2023

Name Yogi M P Singh

Gender Male

Address Surekapuram Colony , Shri Laxmi Narayan Baikunth M , Riva Road, Mirzapur city PIN Code 231001

Country India

State Uttar Pradesh

Status Urban

Educational Status Literate

  Above Graduate

Phone Number +91-7379105911

Mobile Number +91-7379105911

Email-ID yogimpsingh[at]gmail[dot]com

Appeal Details :-

Citizenship Indian

Is the Requester Below Poverty Line ? No

Ground For Appeal Provided Incomplete,Misleading or False Information

CPIO of Public Authority approached DO IC(KY)-Prakash

CPIO's Order/Decision Number Details not provided

CPIO's Order/Decision Date

(Description of Information sought (upto 500 characters)

Prayer or Relief Sought

Where is the name and designation of the staff who processed Diary Number 625103, received on 23-05-2023? This implies incomplete information. Under point 2, CPIO said that request for condonation of delay is not in proper format. Request for condonation of delay received on 12 May 2023 to comply with communication dated 28/04.2023 in respect of diary number-620495/2023. But Deputy registrar CR-1 on 15 May 2023 sought a copy of first appeal and index of documents. Now the same request of condonation of delay attached to the second appeal is not in proper format. Here integrity of staff who processed is under cloud.

Supporting document (only pdf upto 1 MB)

Enter Registration Number CICOM/A/E/23/00191

Name Yogi M P Singh

Received Date 13/06/2023

Public Authority Central Information Commission

Status RTI APPEAL RECEIVED

Date of action 13/06/2023

First Appellate Authority Details :- Details not provided

Nodal Officer Details :-

Telephone Number 011-26172690

Email Id rticell[at]cic[dot]nic[dot]in

To see the attached document to the grievance, click on the link

Central Information Commission may provide information

CIC sought reason to condone delay and appellant submitted but now indiscriminately sought more documents so appeal made again 

Your RTI Request filed successfully.

Please note down the following details for further references.

Registration Number CICOM/R/E/23/00583

Name Yogi M P Singh

Date of Filing 02-06-2023

RTI Fee Received    10

Payment Mode Internet Banking, Credit or Debit Card / RuPay Card, UPI

SBI Reference number IK0CGURUI4

Transaction Status Completed Successfully

Request filed with Central Information Commission

  Contact Details  

Telephone Number 011-26172690

Email Id rticell@cic.nic.in

Online RTI Request Form Details

RTI Request Details :-

   

RTI Request Registration number CICOM/R/E/23/00583

Public Authority Central Information Commission

   

Personal Details of RTI Applicant:-

Name Yogi M P Singh

Gender Male

Address Surekapuram Colony , Shri Laxmi Narayan Baikunth M , Riva Road, Mirzapur city PIN Code 231001

Country India

State Uttar Pradesh

Status Urban

Educational Status Literate

  Above Graduate

Phone Number +91-7379105911

Mobile Number +91-7379105911

Email-ID yogimpsingh[at]gmail[dot]com

Request Details :-

Citizenship Indian

Is the Requester Below Poverty Line ? No

(Description of Information sought (upto 500 characters)

Description of Information Sought

Diary Number 625103, received on 23-05-2023 Yogi M P Singh Surekapuram colony, Shri Laxmi

Narayan Baikunth Mahadev Mandir, Riva Road, Mirzapur city, PIN Code-231001

1-Provide name and designation of staff processed aforementioned diary.

2-Condonation of delay request attached to second appeal not considered. Please provide the reason. Vide attached document.

Concerned CPIO Nodal Officer

Supporting document (only pdf upto 1 MB)

Online RTI Status Form

Note:Fields marked with * are Mandatory.

Enter Registration Number CICOM/R/E/23/00583

Name Yogi M P Singh

Received Date 02/06/2023

Public Authority Central Information Commission

Status RTI REQUEST RECEIVED

Date of action 02/06/2023

Nodal Officer Details :-

Telephone Number 011-26172690

Email Id rticell[at]cic[dot]nic[dot]in

Central Information Commission

CIC Bhawan, Baba Gangnath Marg, Munirka,

New Delhi - 110 067

Diary No:  625103 / 2023Date: 30-05-2023

To:  

Yogi M P Singh

Surekapuram colony, Shri Laxmi

Narayan Baikunth Mahadev Mandir,

Riva Road, Mirzapur city, PIN

Code-231001

, Mirzapur

Uttar Pradesh - 231001

Subject:- Return of Second Appeal along with all documents for removal of deficiencies.

Madam/Sir,

        Reference your Second Appeal dated 23-05-2023 received on  23-05-2023 vide above Diary Number.

2. On scrutiny of the Second Appeal, it is seen that the same has the following deficiencies, which are required to be removed.

         It is noticed that the Second Appeal is time-barred as the same has not been filed within the prescribed time limit and you have not filed any request for condonation of delay.

        Your above mentioned Second appeal is therefore returned, for removing the deficiencies. You are requested to send a Second Appeal complete in all respects.

        While sending the Second appeal a copy of this letter may also be enclosed.

Enclosed as aboveDeputy Registrar(CR)

 

Dak Status

Search Dak

Type

Appeal/Complaint Diary Number Dispatch

Diary Year

2023

Search Type

Diary Number

625103

S.No Diary No. File No. Diary Date Letter Date Applicant Name DAK Status View

1. 625103 -- 23-05-2023 -- Yogi M P Singh Returned to Sender

To see the attached document to the RTI Application, click on the link

Appellant sent hard copy of representation concerning reason to condone delay in submitting second appeal

 Gmail Mahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P Singh <yogimpsingh@gmail.com>

Regarding return of Second Appeal along with all documents for removal of deficiencies.

1 message

Mahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P Singh <yogimpsingh@gmail.com> 4 May 2023 at 11:16

To: Anjali Anand Srivastava <secy-cic@nic.in>, supremecourt <supremecourt@nic.in>, PMO India <connect@mygov.nic.in>, President Secretariat <presidentofindia@rb.nic.in>

The Central information commission sent the following communication on the registered email of the appellant. 

Central Information Commission (CIC) no-reply@nic.in via nic.in 

Tue, 2 May, 12:39 (2 days ago)

to me

Dear Madam/Sir,

Your request details are given below :

1 Appellant Name Yogi M P Singh

2 Address Surekapuram Colony, Shri Laxmi Narayan Baikunth Mahadev Mandir, Riva Road

3 Diary Number 620495

4 Diary Date 24-04-2023

5 Letter Date 01-01-1970

Prayer-Honourable Sir, please condone the delay because this delay is due to cryptic dealings of the public authority High court of Judicature at Allahabad in order to deprive of information to the appellant.  

Following information sought from CPIO High court as follows.

1-Please provide the information regarding the action taken report by the Registrar General, Allahabad High Court on the aforementioned forwarded grievance DEPOJ/E/2019/04435 if not taken any action, then provide the reason as required under subsection 1 d of section 4 of the Right to Information Act 2005.

2-Please provide the Notings made by the accountable public functionaries of the High court of judicature on the aforementioned forwarded grievance DEPOJ/E/2019/04435 by the ministry of justice government of India. 

With due respect, the applicant invites the kind attention of the Honourable Sir to the following submissions as follows.

1-I pray before the Honourable Sir that High Court RTI document attached to this email representation as well as attached to online second appeal diarised as  Diary Number-620495, Diary Date-24-04-2023 which contains four communications exchanged with applicant. Two out of them belong to the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad and the rest of two belong to the ministry of justice. 

2-It is submitted before the Honourable Sir that two point information sought by the appellant concerns the grievance of the applicant registered as DEPOJ/E/2019/04435 forwarded by the ministry of justice for appropriate action to registrar general High Court of Judicature at Allahabad. 

3-CPIO, High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in its communication dated 01 September 2022 and 05 September 2022 stated that grievance of the applicant registered as DEPOJ/E/2019/04435 does not appear to have been received in the office of Honourable court quite obvious from page first and second of the attached PDF document. 

4-Ministry of law and justice again sent communication dated 14 September 2022 with enclosure communication dated 05 December 2019 to registrar general, High Court of Judicature at Allahabad which proved that grievance of the applicant registered as DEPOJ/E/2019/04435 dated 01December 2019 was sent to registrar general, High Court of Judicature at Allahabad and same was also intimated to the appellant quite obvious from third and fourth page of attached PDF document. 

5-If applicant files second appeal without intimating High Court or without proof of the forwarding note of the ministry of justice, then Honourable commission would remain teeth less before the High Court of Judicature so I sought aforementioned proof and sent the proof to executive email of chief justice of High Court and registrar general of High Court of Judicature at Allahabad. Later on hard copy through registered post on 05 December 2022. I waited for a response and meanwhile I submitted representation against CPIO, High court but all went in vain. I think anarchy rules in the High court at Allahabad so being frustrated I submitted a second appeal before the commission. 

This is a humble request of the applicant to you Hon’ble Sir that how can it be justified to withhold public services arbitrarily and promote anarchy, lawlessness, and chaos in an arbitrary manner by making the mockery of law of land? This is the need of the hour to take harsh steps against the wrongdoer in order to win the confidence of citizenry and strengthen the democratic values for healthy and prosperous democracy. For this, your applicant shall ever pray to you, Hon’ble Sir.                                                                                               Yours sincerely

Date-04/05/2023              Yogi M. P. Singh, Mobile number-7379105911, Mohalla- Surekapuram, Riva Road, District-Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh, Pin code-231001.

2 attachments

img012.jpg

28K

Highcourt RTI document.pdf

1099K