Online RTI First Appeal Status Form
Note:Fields marked with * are Mandatory.
Enter Registration Number CICOM/A/E/23/00269
Name Yogi M P Singh
Received Date 01/08/2023
Public Authority Central Information Commission
Status APPEAL DISPOSED OF
Date of action 31/08/2023
Reply :- Ref RTI No.- CICOM/R/E/23/00853
GROUNDS FOR FIRST APPEAL:
The Appellant submitted first appeal stating that
“CPIO did not tell the reason for considering request for condonation of delay as second appeal ipso facto so provided information by CPIO is incomplete. 1-Second page is the request for condonation of delay on the format provided by the central registry. Let me tell you the reason for considering it as a second appeal. Reply of CPIO is as -Your Second appeal vide Diary Number 121423 was examined by Mr Anoop ASO Respected Madam-communication of the applicant dated 09-05-2023 received on 12-05-2023 attached as second page diarised as Diary Number 121423 is a request for condonation of delay not second appeal as claimed incompetent CPIO. Vide second page of attached PDF document. This request for condonation of delay is in compliance with communication dated 28 April 2023 of deputy registrar CR-1 attached as third page of PDF document.”
DECISION OF THE FIRST APPELLATE AUTHORITY:
The First Appeal, RTI application and reply given by CPIO of CIC have been perused.
As per Section 2(f) of the RTI Act, 2005 only such information as is available and existing and held by the public authority or is under control of the public authority can be provided by a PIO. The PIO is not supposed to create or collate information that is not a part of the record.
Accordingly, the reply given by the CPIO is appropriate and as per the provisions of the RTI Act, 2005. Hence, no intervention is required on behalf of the FAA in this matter.
The appeal is disposed of accordingly.
First Appellate Authority Details :- Ms[dot] ROOP AVTAR KAUR
Phone: 011-26162290
as-cic[at]nic[dot]in
Nodal Officer Details :-
Telephone Number 011-26172690
Email Id rticell[at]cic[dot]nic[dot]in
Online RTI Appeal Form Details
RTI Appeal Details :-
RTI Appeal Registration number CICOM/A/E/23/00269
Public Authority Central Information Commission
Personal Details of Appellant:-
Request Registration Number CICOM/R/E/23/00853
Request Registration Date 26/07/2023
Name Yogi M P Singh
Gender Male
Address Surekapuram colony, Shri Laxmi Narayan Baikunth Ma , Riva Road, Mirzapur city PIN Code 231001
Country India
State Uttar Pradesh
Status Urban
Educational Status Literate
Above Graduate
Phone Number Details not provided
Mobile Number +91-7379105911
Email-ID yogimpsingh[at]gmail[dot]com
Appeal Details :-
Citizenship Indian
Is the Requester Below Poverty Line ? No
Ground For Appeal Provided Incomplete,Misleading or False Information
CPIO of Public Authority approached DO IC(KY)-Prakash
CPIO's Order/Decision Number Details not provided
CPIO's Order/Decision Date
(Description of Information sought (upto 500 characters)
Prayer or Relief Sought
CPIO did not tell the reason for considering request for condonation of delay as second appeal ipso facto so provided information by CPIO is incomplete.
1-Second page is the request for condonation of delay on the format provided by the central registry. Let me tell you the reason for considering it as a second appeal.
Reply of CPIO is as -Your Second appeal vide Diary Number 121423 was examined by Mr Anoop ASO
Respected Madam-communication of the applicant dated 09-05-2023 received on 12-05-2023 attached as second page diarised as Diary Number 121423 is a request for condonation of delay not second appeal as claimed incompetent CPIO. Vide second page of attached PDF document. This request for condonation of delay is in compliance with communication dated 28 April 2023 of deputy registrar CR-1 attached as third page of PDF document.
Supporting document (only pdf upto 1 MB)
To see the attached document to the RTI appeal, click on the link