Directorate of Agriculture Lucknow Transferred RTI application to DDA illegally



Mr. Yogi M P Singh Welcome to Our Online Portal.

Text size Feature

Uttar Pradesh

English

Welcome : UPICR20240000149

Registration Number : A-20240700274

File Number : S09/A/0983/2024

UTTAR PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION

Diary Number - D-290920240001

Citizen Details

Name Yogi M P Singh

Mobile Number 7379105911

Email yogimpsingh@gmail.com

Address सुरेकापुरम कॉलोनी जबलपुर रोड मिर्जापुर सिटी

Public Information Officer Details

PIO DDA MIRZAPUR

Address नाम :DDA MIRZAPUR,पता : Public Information Officer Office - Agriculture Department,Mirzapur Distrcit,पिन कोड : 231001

Case Status

Hearing Date 05/08/2024

Hearing Status For further hearing.

Hearing Room S-9

Documents Enclosure

Document-1 Details

Content provided & maintained by Uttar Pradesh Information Commission.

UTTAR PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION Second Appeal under section 19(3) of the Right to Information Act, 2005

Appeal Registration Number - A-20240700274, File Number - S09/A/0983/2024

To

Respected information commissioner

शकुन्तला गौतम, मा० राज्य सूचना आयुक्त, सुनवाई कक्ष एस-9

Subject-Regarding email dated-27 Sept 2024, 17:04 (2 days ago) of DDA Mirzapur.

Short Submissions of the appellant are as follows.

1-     In the first para of the RTI application the appellant mentioned as-

The information concerns the directorate of Agriculture Lucknow so it must not be provided to deputy director agriculture division Mirzapur because Nodal officer and PIO directorate have already made the mockery of the RTI Act 2005 by illegal transfer. Registration Number DRAGR/R/2023/60053 Name Yogi M P Singh Date of Filing 26/07/2023 Status REQUEST TRANSFERRED TO OTHER PIO as on 21/08/2023.

2-     From the point 1, it is obvious that the appellant sought information from the directorate of Agriculture not deputy director agriculture district Mirzapur.

3-     If the information does not concern with the deputy director of agriculture, how can he provide information to the appellant?

4-     Nodal officer overlooked the request of the appellant deliberately and transferred the RTI application to the deputy director of Agriculture Mirzapur which was illegal because in formation was concerned with the working of the directorate of Agriculture Lucknow.

5-     Registration Number     DRAGR/R/2024/60004 Name Yogi M P Singh

Date of Filing         20/01/2024 Status          REQUEST DISPOSED OF as on 09/08/2024

This implies that near about seven months taken to attach information on the RTI portal which was misleading.

6-     Moreover if the information does not concern with the deputy director of agriculture Mirzapur then it was his obligatory duty to transfer the RTI application under subsection 3 of section 6 of the right to information act to directorate of agricultural Lucknow but he had no courage to do it.

7-    The appellant is seeking following information from the public information officer and public information officer has violated subsection 1 of section 7 of the right to information act 2005.

1-It is quite obvious that Status Verified By District and Pending for Approval at State Level. The Public Information Officer should provide the name and designation of the staff who is processing the aforementioned online application awaiting approval of the state government.

The information denied it was concerned with the working of the directorate of Agriculture Lucknow.

2-Public Information Officer should provide the transparency mechanism to process such applications received from the district level for approval of online applications for the prime minister Kisan Samman Nidhi.

DDA provided misleading information because this information concerns with the working of the directorate of Agriculture Lucknow.

3- Public Information Officer should provide the maximum span of time taken by the directorate, department of agriculture government of Uttar Pradesh to provide the approval in such matters.

DDA replied as-The maximum span of time taken in approval of the said scheme was not specified. This information also concerns with the working of the directorate of Agriculture Lucknow.

4- Public Information Officer should provide the posting details of the staff who are employed in this particular section who are engaged in the processing of the prime minister Kisan Samman Nidhi applications for approval at the state level.

DDA denied information because this information concerns the working of the directorate of Agriculture Lucknow.

5- Public Information Officer should provide the posting details of the director of the department of agriculture government of Uttar Pradesh and his name.

DDA provided as- Name: Dr. Jitendra Kumar Tomar, Post: Director

Where is the posting details of the director?

Most respected madam whether the appellants will be denied information in this way by the public authorities as they have transferred the matter to the other public authority which is not the custodian of the information and even when it was humbly requested by the appellant not to do so.

This is a humble request of the appellant to the most respected madam to be instrumental in providing information to the appellant, For this appellant shall ever pray you most respected madam.

Date-29/09/2024                                            O God help me

 

Yogi M P Singh Mobile number 7379105911

 

Notice issued dated 05-08-2024 by the respected commission and the denial of information by the public information officer dated 27th September 2024 is also attached as the next pages.

शकुन्तला गौतम, मा० राज्य सूचना आयुक्त, सुनवाई कक्ष एस-9

अपील संख्या एस 09/ए/0983/2024

श्री योगी एम०पी० सिंह बनाम ज०सू०अ० कार्यालय कृषि विभाग, जनपद-मीरजापुर

आदेश

कम्प्लेन्ट व अपील ट्रैकिंग सिस्टम (CATS) के माध्यम से पंजीकृत की गयी अपील आज दिनांक 05.08.2024 को सुनवाई हेतु प्रस्तुत की गयी है। दिनांक-05.08.2024 की सुनवाई हेतु उभयपक्षों को दिनांक-31.07.2024 को पंजीकृत डाक के माध्यम से नोटिस प्रेषित की गयी। पत्रावली पेश हुई। पुकार करायी गयी। उभयपक्ष अनुपस्थित है।

नैसर्गिक न्याय के दृष्टिगत विपक्षी जनसूचना अधिकारी कार्यालय कृषि विभाग, जनपद-मीरजापुर को आज पारित आदेश की प्रति संलग्न कर नोटिस प्रेषित की जाये कि वह सूचना का अधिकार अधिनियम 2005 व उ०प्र० सूचना का अधिकार नियमावली, 2015 के नियमों व प्राविधानों के अनुसार अपीलार्थी के आवेदन पत्र का निस्तारण करते हुए निस्तारण आख्या/सूचना नियत तिथि से पूर्व अपीलार्थी को उपलब्ध करायें एवं निस्तारण आख्या एवं लिखित अभिकथन नियत सुनवाई तिथि पर आयोग को उपलब्ध करायी जाये।

अपील में अपीलार्थी को नोटिस प्रेषित की जाये।

पत्रावली सुनवाई हेतु दिनांक-27.09.2024 को पेश हो।

05.08.2024

पंजीकृत / ई-मेल/वाट्सएप

प्रेषक,

उप कृषि निदेशक, मीरजापुर

सेवा में,

योगी एम पी सिंह, पुत्र राजेन्द्र प्रताप सिंह, सुरेकापुरम कालोनी, जबलपुर रोड, मीरजापुर-231001 ।

पत्रांक- ५०70/जन-सूचना/पी०एम०किसान/2024-25 महोदय,

दिनांक-27-9-24

कृपया अपने अपील संख्या-S09/A/0983/2024 दिनांक 31-07-2024 का संदर्भ ग्रहण करने की कृपा करें, जिसके सापेक्ष चाही गई सूचना निम्नवत् है।

The demanded information are as follows:-

i-The name and designation of the staff who is processing the online application awaiting approval of the state government is concerned with Directorate of Agriculture, Uttar Pradesh Lucknow. So, it is not possible at this level to provide details of such staff.

ii- The farmer who wants the benefit of Pradhan Mantri Kisan Samman Nidhi Yojana first get the registration for it from CSC (Common Service Centre). After that the land details are being verified by respective Tehsil and then the application was forwarded online to Deputy Director Agricuture login and then it is forwarder to Directorate of Agriculture, Uttar Pradesh Lucknow.

The maximum span of time taken in approval of the said scheme was not specified.

iv- The posting details of the staff who are employed in a particular section and engaged in the processing of the PM Kisan Samman Nidhi application for approval at state level are concerned with Directorate of Agriculture, Uttar Pradesh Lucknow. So, it is not possible at this level to provide details of such staff.

V- Posting details of the director of the department of agriculture Government of Uttar Pradesh are-

Name: Dr. Jitendra Kumar Tomar

Post: Director

Department Name: Directorate of Agriculture, Uttar Pradesh Lucknow

भवदीय, (विकेश कुमार), उप कृषि निदेशक, मीरजापुर

पत्रांक- / जन-सूचना/पी०एम०किसान / 2024-25 दिनांकित । प्रतिलिपि - निम्नलिखित को सूचनार्थ एवं आवश्यक कार्यवाही हेतु प्रेषित-

1- संयुक्त कृषि निदेशक, विन्ध्याचल मण्डल मीरजापुर।

2- अपर कृषि निदेशक (भूमि संरक्षण) / योजनाधिकारी, उ०प्र० कृषि भवन लखनऊ।

3- कृषि निदेशक, उ०प्र० कृषि भवन लखनऊ।

4- मा० राज्य सूचना आयुक्त, उ०प्र० सूचना आयोग, 7/7/ए, आरटीआई भवन, विभूति खंड, गोमती नगर, लखनऊ की सेवा में सादर अवलोकनार्थ प्रेषित।

उप कृषि निदेशक, मीरजापुर





Yogi

An anti-corruption crusader. Motive to build a strong society based on the principle of universal brotherhood. Human rights defender and RTI activist.

Post a Comment

Your view points inspire us

Previous Post Next Post